pianoloverus I assume this idea is mostly geared towards beginners or low intermediates because beyond that I don't think any pianist ever learns anywhere near 40 pieces a year or even 25 pieces a year.
Agreed. I said as much in my opening post.
ShiroKuro I note your point that the original concept was that the 40 pieces should be in addition to other pieces. My approach is pretty relaxed as I'm not working towards exams, but I recognise that in order to grow my piano skills I need to play some stretch pieces. It's a matter of choice whether to count stretch pieces as part of the 40 pieces and in my case I plan to count them, but aim for a total near to 50 pieces, rather than 40.
I don't mind people discussing the pros and cons of the concept here, although it might make the thread quite unwieldy as time goes on, so perhaps it might be better to have those discussions on the other thread (see link in my OP).
I enjoy watching the videos of fellow players, but there's no obligation for anyone to post videos and I wonder if perhaps this thread might become a bit glitchy/overloaded if it turns into a year round recital thread? I'm not tech minded so perhaps someone who knows about this stuff could offer guidance around this point. Anyway, we could always start another thread, perhaps at the 6 month point, if this one becomes unusable.
"Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)