- Edited
I've been trying to get a good tuning on my piano since my tech was forced into early retirement due to an injury a year ago. The first guy did put a nice perfect 12ths tuning on my piano using his app, but I didn't like him. He seemed dismissive and I want someone who will listen to me and who makes me feel respected. Then I found another guy who is meticulous and thoughtful, but he also tunes using an app and after several tunings it just wasn't working. My piano used to sing and now it doesn't; apparently Bƶsendorfers have low inharmonicity so the app tells it to do very little stretch, and the 3rds sounds bad and the piano didn't sing. He had tried more stretch but then the 6ths sounded bad. Anyway, after a year of trying different things with the tuning settings (because I really wanted things to work out with him) I finally gave up.
My former tech recommended a guy but he lives two hours away. He's willing to come to Portland but the travel fee would be $240 If I can find him other clients the fee can be split.
Anyway, he happens to be in town for a PTG meeting today so he's here and is waiving the travel fee. He's a talker and he loves pianos (and plays classical piano well, which is not something I've encountered in the techs I've used) and is such a huge geek and knows so much about pianos and I really like him already. He tunes by ear and he said he became friends (through a Zoom book club during the pandemic!) with the tech who took over tuning at the White House from Franz Mohr back in the day! That guy says instead of making the octaves sound really good, he makes the 5ths sound really good and then within those tries to make the minor 3rds and the 4ths sound good. This guy said that's what he does now and he thinks it makes the tunings sound better.
He warned me when he started his tuning, he said it'll around really weird and bad before it sounds better. He said his mentor always said that for a concert tuning you never want a flat treble, that's death. But as you tune, it changes the tension on the piano! So he went and very quickly added a bit of tension to just one string of every note (it did sound terrible and weird!). He said that as he tunes, then the overall tension of the whole piano won't change.
Anyway, he's tuning now and I have high hopes that he can make my piano sound really good again. I think he's very good at what he does and my former tech would not have recommended him if he didn't think very highly of him. We'll see how it goes and then, well, I guess if I want him to come down I'll just have to pay a lot. Maybe I can see if one of my former tech's other clients wants to go in with me on the travel fee.