navindra The thread is open for comments from everyone.
If I understand correctly, each recital will be housed in a single discussion thread containing:
- An introductory message from the Recital Coordinator (RC), followed by
- Submissions from recital participants (which need to be submitted prior to the recital deadline), followed by
- Comments from everyone
I think it's a good plan! Depending on how much time the RCs can dedicate, I think the following items would be nice to add to the introductory message, once the deadline has passed:
- A playlist of all youtube submissions
- A table of contents that can double as a template for comments. For example, if this thread were a recital, then:
RECITAL SUBMISSIONS
navindra - I'm Running A Bit Behind (Chopin)
TC3 - Looks Good (Elton John)
HeartKeys - Thanks for All the Diligence (Prokofiev)
Users could then make comments by copying/pasting the above and then adding their comments:
navindra - I'm Running A Bit Behind (Chopin) You sound like you are on tempo and not behind at all!
TC3 - Looks Good (Elton John) You are looking good!
HeartKeys - Thanks for All the Diligence (Prokofiev) Sounds like a really hard piece that I would never be able to perform.
(EDIT: Is there any way to view the actual markup of a post? If I quote the "table of contents" in the usual manner, it doesn't come out properly).