PianoTell Recital #2 Is Now Live!
thepianoplayer416 โ When You Wish Upon a Star
That's a pretty piece, which is harder to play than it first seems. There were some slight irregularities with the tempo but it was nonetheless enjoyable.
Sam โ The Never Finished Piece
That was a nice relaxing piece which could be used as the music score for a romantic drama series. Your experience shows and is paying dividends.
MarieJ โ Waltz in F minor
I love a waltz and this one was no exception. Beautifully played and the artwork was great too.
Player1 โ Ashokan Farewell
That's a lovely piece which I'd never heard before and it's just the kind of music I enjoy. There were some hesitations but you played with a delicate touch and I liked it very much.
Rubens โ Sonata no.2, Op.36 (1913), 2nd movement
Another piece that was new to my ears, which you played very well. You captured the mysterious mood of this piece beautifully.
Cratersmash โ Sonata No. 3 in A Minor
This piece is so complex that I'd not be able to play it in a million years. You played it well - impressive work.
"Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)
Congratulations everybody! What a great playlist for listening to in the next few days!
Also, thank you @navindra for all that you do โ this forum with its recitals is one of the best things ever
navindra I never tire of this tune, itโs so cheerful and energetic! I like your tempo and dynamic choices. And listening to your highly enjoyable playing has made me smile and want to jump and go to the piano and try to play it too!
Cratersmash โ Sonata No. 3 in A Minor Wonderful playing! I'm hoping to work my way up to Prokofiev soon (even his Children's Pieces are pretty difficult). There was some percussion throughout starting in the middle section - was that your foot or something? I thought it actually fit really well and now I'm wondering what this sonata would sound like with a full percussion section.
javiercorre โ Sonatas K. 208 and K. 380 I'd say you're ready for your recital. Scarlatti was truly ahead of his time.
plop_symphony โ The Midnight Ball
This one was really spooky - a very nice match to Halloween. I just couldn't tell if you played here and there a mistake, but it sounded so off, to be good again. Guess this was the way the sheet music told you to play.
- Edited
Just another few comments - this time from the final few pieces. I'll listen to the middle section another day.
Sgisela โ Do Tebe (to you)
Wow, that's a beautiful piece and you played it effortlessly - you are clearly a natural! How long have you been playing piano? Also, I also loved the way you started and ended the piece with a close up of sunflowers - very nice!
ShiroKuro โ Reminiscence
Another piece new to my ears and what a treat it was! I love the way the piece creates the effect of rippling water and you played it beautifully.
Pathbreaker โ Larghetto
Beautifully played and your hands are beautiful too - an added bonus for viewers!
diretonic โ Chega de Saudade (No More Blues)
Now that's jazz! I agree that it sounds quite busy in parts, but then I'm not an afficionado of this type of music so maybe others really like the busy sections?
navindra โ The Entertainer
Nav you nailed it! I played this arrangement a few months back, but never managed to play it as fluently and confidently as you do. Plus you had the satisfaction of pushing the total number of submissions just one digit higher (not that anyone's keeping tally with another forum, oh no...)
"Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)
- Edited
WieWaldi Thank you! There's a lot of grace notes and minor seconds in the piece. There is one bit where I miss the main note and play only the grace note, and some bits where the inner note is more prominent than the outer note when it shouldn't be. Other than that, everything that sounds off was written that way by the composer.
Thank you for your kind words , Nightowl. It is interesting that someone like you, never getting tired to claim that Blues isn't the genre of favour, quite often likes a Blues.
I could consider this as a compliment (thank you again), or state the following:
Nightowl โ What A Wonderful World
This is indeed a very nice song - love it. And it contains:
(drum roll)
A Blues Scale!
Actually I heard besides the Blues scale a lot of Blues elements in your piece. And I had to look up in wikipedia about its genre: It says "pop". Ok, we can forget about pop, because you can basically consider every song as pop, when it was popular at its time. Same is true for Mozart - back in his days his music was pop music.
The second mentioned genre is:
(drum roll again)
Rhythm & Blues . A progression of the Blues genre! Blues itself is IMO the easiest genre of all - except of nursery rhymes maybe. But the children of Blues (Boogie, Rock, Jazz, R&B) aren't that easy anymore. You played a quite long piece from a not so easy genre, I mean over 21/2 minutes. Here and there, you hesitated a bit and some notes came a bit late. Still, you hit the essence of this piece. With less than 1 year of self-teaching, I call this really impressive. Give yourself a big hug and then some taps on your shoulder, you can be proud of your progress.
One thing I can not tell for sure is your sitting position in front of the piano. I can't tell for sure because I see only your hands, but I have the impression you are sitting quite low. This makes playing a lot harder, especially for beginners. I don't want to step into this deeper, but if you need help, there is a wonderful piano forum with a lot of amazing players, willing to help you, if you ask...
rogerch โ Slow Steps
One can really tell, you are enjoying to improvise. It looks like a fish in the water. I've heard this style of impro already from you, last time it was good, this time it is good again. Just different, but still with your own signature.
I enjoyed to listen to the beautiful sound, the warmth, the harmony, you did very well changing between Major and minor, here and there (at least I believe, you did). You made a good mix between repeating the known melodies to please the listener and introducing new themes to keep in interesting. I'd call this well rounded improvisation again.
Well done, Roger, I bow to you in respect!
thepianoplayer416 โ When You Wish Upon a Star
Such a lovely melody (one of my favourites) and well played! And you did that robot voice thingie again It was also nice that you provided the lyrics. Very enjoyable performance, thank you!
Sam โ The Never Finished Piece
It sounds very familiar and yet it isn't... because it came straight from your brain And even though you called it "Never finished piece", it finished all too soon ^_^ I half expected you'd just stop mid bar, but no, you did give it a proper ending, haha. Very nice and gentle piece!
MarieJ โ Waltz in F minor
That was truly gorgeous! From the lovely imagery, the gentle yet powerful playing, and such a very, very pretty melody. It just gently moves along and leaves you with nothing but pleasant thoughts and a great feeling. The quality was very good too, so obviously your digital coming of age worked really well
iternabe โ O mio babbino caro - Itโs a beautiful aria, and you really make your piano sing it!
- Edited
@lilypad - God Bless the Child. What a beautiful tune! Thatโs a song Iโve always wished I had the voice to pull off. I know what you mean about the rhythmic style. I think it sounds just fine with a steady beat, but you could definitely continue experimenting with some rubato here and there. Cheers!
@BicBic - Prelude. Short and sweet! Thanks for the selection, I admit I donโt know Scriabin at all, so youโve broadened my horizons. You have very good technique, I thought the rolled chords near the end were especially well executed.
@WieWaldi - Quick Five Blues. All right, now this is my kind of music! Though Iโve only messed around with some of Christianโs videos in no particular order, I definitely recognize some of the elements from his lessons. Your left hand shuffle is very nice, youโve really nailed that since the first time I saw you play a Christian lesson on PW a couple of years ago. Keep it up!
Enthusiastic but mediocre amateur.