I began on alto sax, age 9, but asked for an electric bass at age 14 and started playing in a rock band, junior high, didn't really like the lead guitarist, and didn't like a lot of the songs we played, but was hooked on the notoriety and, well, perks of playing in a local band. Eventually, having grown tired of compromises, I picked up guitar (no pun intended), got into blues, learned slide, and started my own band, which was a little better than playing in someone else's band.

As I got older, I returned to the sax, tenor this time, and got into jazz, classic stuff like Miles Davis "Kind Of Blue", Dexter Gordon, standards, swing, some be-bop, had some good groups, piano, bass, drums, sax, and even had two tenors for a while, which was the most fun I ever had playing. After a while, jazz gigs were harder to find, and things dissolved. So, I decided the piano was the best way the express myself, can play a whole tune (unlike sax, which really needs a rhythm section), no compromises, play exactly what I want, how I want. And that's worked for any gigs I might pick up, agree on a duration and price, play what I want, or no gig. Simple, really. Fits my personality and my frame of mind. Should have gone this route to begin with.

I still play guitar, some classical, some electric, but the only band I have is either Band In A Box or GarageBand.

Nice to see some fellow school band geeks here! 🙂 Saxophone was my instrument as a kid (4th grade on), but I haven't done much more than noodle on it since I graduated high school. I didn't take up upright bass until my last couple of years of high school, but enjoyed playing in orchestra quite a bit.


Enthusiastic but mediocre amateur.

    JB_PT I'm still a band geek at heart. I played clarinet (like you, if I remember correctly?) with a symphonic band until a few years ago. Unfortunately I had to quit due to an ear injury caused and exacerbated by the loudness of a full band.
    But I miss playing with others. A friend of mine and I have talked about getting together regularly to play classical guitar duets but due to injuries, work schedules etc we've still not managed to make it happen. Hopefully one day...

      candela Clarinet, yes. I'm sorry about your ear problem, that must be really hard! I have an Apple Watch and every rehearsal it squawks at me multiple times about being in a loud environment. 😐 Our conductor has been at it for probably over 50 years now...it's amazing that he still seems to have good hearing!

        JB_PT Thanks. Well, it is what it is, and I'm happy there are other instruments I can still play and enjoy. My hearing is overall very good, but my left ear can't handle loud sounds in general and certain particular sounds at any volume any more as they get terribly distorted and painful. I also have a never-ending pulsating tinnitus in that ear. It all appeared from one second to the next during a fortissimo by someone on the row behind in a rehearsal back in 2006. I'm suspecting it's a case of superior semicircular canal dehiscence. For several years afterwards I could kind-of get by in band by using ear plugs, but eventually even the strongest -26 dB filters didn't cut it. In retrospect it is obvious I should have worn ear protection from the very start. You don't know for sure until it's too late what injuries you might have a predisposition for.
        Sorry about possible over-sharing but if it would make a single person protect their hearing before it's too late that makes it worth it in my book.

          candela It all appeared from one second to the next during a fortissimo by someone on the row behind in a rehearsal back in 2006.

          Yikes...that does give me something to think about. Often I'm sitting right in front of the trumpets. That's unpleasant for multiple reasons, but I hadn't considered the idea that they could literally break my ears. Thanks for sharing!

            JB_PT I hadn't considered the idea that they could literally break my ears.

            Yeah, I know... We've probably all heard about ear damages caused by explosions and such, and also about the deterioration of hearing and increase of tinnitus over time in loud environments, but this? No, I had no idea either before it happened to me.

            I played tenor sax in the high school band, not because I particularly liked band, but was just sort of on auto-pilot scholastically. At the same time, I played in some very popular local rock bands, mostly with older guys. I was a brat, with a big ego. In the high school stage band (some schools call it jazz band) I was pretty much the go to soloist, and because of that I was able to ditch all parades, football games, and pep rallies. Did I mention I was a brat?

            • TC3 likes this.

            Not in a band per se, but I have been the accompanist in a number of amateur jam sessions.

            Being in a band is a commitment, one that I don't feel like I have the time or energy for at the moment. Maybe piano for me in its purest form is also something where I'm allowed to be myself and don't have to bend to the whims of others.

              ranjit That's definitely why I took up piano, I wanted to be able to make music on my own. I missed the band thing after a while, but our current trio is me, my spouse, and a good friend, and we're keeping it very casual, so that takes the pressure off.


              Enthusiastic but mediocre amateur.

              a month later

              Hi

              I've been playing in bands since the late 1980s. The first band I ever played was "The Sheds Jackson Trio" a Jazz trio consisting of Piano, bass and drums. Over the decades I've been lucky enough to play some decent gigs, perhaps most memorably playing in a band that was the support act for Buddy Whittington (an American blues guitarist). The gig was played at the Mick Jagger Centre (Kent, UK), not a huge venue, but nevertheless we were supporting a professional act, and it felt good! In fact my avatar picture was taken at that gig, back in 2010.

              Although I returned to serious classical playing in late 2022 and am working towards my ABRSM grade 8, I still play in a rock/pop band, where I actually play more drums than keyboards. I shall probably do more gigs this year, with that band, than I have in more than a decade. I also attend a regular rock/pop jam session every fortnight and in theory rehearse with an amateur big band once a fortnight, but this seems to be on the wane.

              I'm very lucky to have my own rehearsal space at the bottom of my garden. Tonight I'm hosting a monthly Jazz jam I have in it with a few friends. Over the years it's been used on a regular basis to play with quite a few different combinations of musicians/friends.

              So the short answer to your question is yes 🙂

              Cheers

              Simon
              All round average Jazz, Blues & Rock player.
              Currently working towards ABRSM grade 8.

              a month later

              Piano not yet. Violin definitely with a local orchestra.

              • TC3 likes this.