Haha I fully embraced my crude side there and loved Hokey Pokey! All jokes aside though, I think it is a good exercise in many ways - especially the parts where the left is staccato throughout and the right hand alternates between staccato (easy) and legato (hard!). Plus it has a lot of syncopation and other tricky parts. It's probably quite a bit trickier to play than you'd expect from such a silly piece!

The Lullaby version is the second book is a lot nicer than the one in book 1 - you missed nothing there. But yeah, hang in there, the latter part of this book really has some gorgeous pieces and they are not ALL excruciatingly hard to play. I expect that this new piece is going to be hard though... but completely worth it. Definitely not something I'll be able to play flawlessly anytime soon. It's probably something I will not be able to perfect in one go, and will have to continue to get back to it even after I moved on to other pieces.

Sophia, from what you said I think that Hokey P is that deadly combo - tricky but annoying! I really dislike the strident tone and style of the piece, which seems to scream "You WILL enjoy yourself! This is FUN!" As I type this I'm suppressing ancient memories of wedding receptions when this piece was played and everyone was encouraged onto their feet to perform the hideous dance that went with it.... shudder. Now, as then, I reserve the right not to participate in this annoying abomination! 😬
<Flounces off and ponders how it's possible for someone with such innate musicality to enjoy inflicting such a horrible sound upon herself, unless she has masochistic tendencies.>

"Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

Hehehehehe.... You be careful now... if you keep going like that I might record a version that doesn't involve kittens and play it on a loop for you 😂

    That's fine Sophia, I really enjoyed that video, especially when I muted the sound! 🤣 The kitten seemed determined to sabotage your performance - I can't think why?!? 🙃

    "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

    Well, you asked for it.... here's my new toy in combination your all time favourite tune. I even added some improvisation at the recommendation of @rogerch. Plus a sneak preview of our screened in patio for the cats (and ourselves) to enjoy. Life doesn't get much better than that 😂🤣🤣

      Sophia Very fun! Sophia you're a natural!

        There are no words... 😂

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

        4 days later

        Player1 I blame you P1, Sophia has always been your favourite, you've never been as stern with her as with the rest of us, so it's not surprising she's gone completely off the rails.

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

            Nightowl

            Me?????? No way. She even said it was rogerch whodunnit.

            See this is how bad reputation start. Not that I don't deserve a bad reputation, but I'd like to get one on my own instead of being saddled with someone else's.

              Hehehehehe!!! But I'm having so much fuuuuunnn!!!

              Actually, I was about to post some progress (or lack thereof) in the blues thread, but I'll do it here. I'm still trying to get Salut d'amour in my fingers. It's a slow progress, as expected, but I can now play the first half okay-ish, albeit ever so slowly. The second half is still very much a WIP! It's such a pretty piece though that I don't mind spending a few weeks with it... it'll be worth it.

              Alfred book 2 is nearing its end, but as with the last pieces in the first book, these seem quite a bit harder all of a sudden. I might have to spend as much time on the last 5 pieces as the entire first half of the book 🤔 I'm keeping my fingers crossed that there isn't a Laura type piece hidden within those last pages!

              The blues lesson (yeah I know, I should report it in the other thread) is a very long one, with no less than four new licks to master. There too I'm about halfway now - two licks mastered, two still to learn 🙂

              The REAL bad one was @Rubens - he filled my big head with kitten pianos. That simply proved irresistible. Though @rogerch is to blame for talking me into improvising, that's true 😃 Of course you were the one who made me feel welcome in the other forum @Player1 and caused me to stick around - so you're definitely not without blame! 😛

                Sophia

                Guilty as charged! I take full blame. May the others be freed immediately and may I endure the punishment that will be for Sophia to choose. I know it will be a difficult choice. (Sophia's Choice, get it?).

                  Haha ohhh my punishment is severe... 😃 How about you treat us to a little performance someday in either the recitals or the Member recordings section?

                  Seriously though: no pressure 😃 I'm teasing all in good fun!

                    Sophia
                    Your wish is my command. Your desire is my order. I will participate, someday 😅.

                      Sophia

                      I never did say I was completely blameless but I'm thinking it's maybe around 2%. Kind of like that milk that isn't really milk. So whatever blame is on me, isn't really any blame at all.

                      I did play again today. Just re-familiarizing myself with Wolf though, nothing from the lesson book.

                        Blame? Why are you all talking about blame??

                        It’s credit!! Kudos to Sophia for the awesome meowprovisation, riffing on top of the classic hokey pokey on such a fun innovative instrument!

                        I am honored that anyone thinks that I may have played a tiny part in any of this. Really I did nothing, it’s all Sophia with possibly an assist from Rubens.

                        Blame? Sheesh!!

                          rogerch

                          So you're saying it's all Sophia's fault we turned her into a musical monster?

                              Player1 Ha ha ha, "musical monster" indeed! 🤣😆😂🙃 Well, I guess Sophia has found her inner child and this is only going to get worse. The signs were there when she admitted to enjoying Little Brown Jug in book 1, and now she's picked the worst piece in book 2 to relentlessly torment us with - she truly is an incorrigible child!
                              That said, as @Rubens so brilliantly said above, it's Sophia's Choice, and however naughty she is we love her anyway. 🙂

                              @rogerch - I'm not sure that you should be rewarding her bad behaviour with praise - it will only encourage her! 😁
                              [I'm off to find some earplugs before the next onslaught from naughty Sophia.]

                              "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

                                I love this forum