hebele Hi hebele, thank you for the welcome and link to the Faber's discussion. I'll check it out later.

As I mentioned, I'm only up to New World Symphony Theme right now, but if I had to pick my least favorite so far it would be the one before this piece called Eine Kleine Nachtmusik. I wouldn't go so far as to label it dire, but those were some weird (to me anyway) slurs in the middle of the piece.

I'm curious, did you just do audio only or video recordings? I think what I don't want is to see myself playing, though I get how that might be useful to monitor posture.

    iternabe Thanks for the suggestion. I'll check it out. As for what I have right now it would just be my cheap Android phone. It works for cat videos, which is all I've ever recorded with it, so I guess I don't really have any excuses for not giving it a try.

    Player1 Conspire? Us? Noooooooooo, we'd never... πŸ˜‡

    Do you guys have a code name for this black ops mission? Haha, just kidding.

    I'll work on it. I swear!!

      Sophia I never had piano lessons, but I dabbled with it five years before I started again last January. Back then I had no idea there was such a thing as Internet learning. When I found his channel it was like a light bulb went on above my head... the way he explained dynamics, melody hand louder, etc. I also learned to use the pedal for the first time, though it so happened that it suddenly became clear(er) after a post in this forum. So much to learn still!

      For sure! That's why after I found his channel I went back and redid the pieces. Before I was pretty much just focused on hitting the right notes.

      Sophia Glad you're enjoying your learning! I am not familiar with the other books you use, but for Alfred, the rite of passage is basically Blow the Man Down. It is surprisingly tricky to learn, so if you survive that one without blowing your piano up, from then on you can boast that you play piano πŸ˜‚

      I just took a peak at the contents list and see that it's on page 89. and I'm on page 45. So not sure how long that will take before I find out if my piano blows up.

      Sophia Speaking of which, I'm not sure if you mentioned it but what piano did you purchase?

      It's a Casio Privia PX-850. It looks really nice and everything I've tried on it so far seems to work just fine. Not that I'm really sure about all the settings. I decided to leave it on the grand piano concert setting.

        Animisha Recording for your own sake and for uploading to this forum are two very separate things. Don't let yourself get stressed by someone who thinks you should upload. I am a very active member here at PianoTell and so far I have not participated in any recitals or in another way uploaded my videos. Nobody has held this against me.
        So please feel free to participate in the way that suits you best.

        Thank you, I really appreciate that. I have seen a lot of your posts and enjoy reading them along with everyone elses.

        Kaydia I'm curious, did you just do audio only or video recordings? I think what I don't want is to see myself playing, though I get how that might be useful to monitor posture.

        I use Pianoteq which records everything played as midi. That's audio only. I am way too lazy to setup a camera. But I really should. For first 6 months I thought I didn't have major problems with my technique. Then (surprise, surprise) I've realised that some of my fingers are collapsing during play. If I was video recording, I would be aware of it much sooner.

        Kaydia

        It's called "Operation Steinway." It used to be called "Operation Shooting Star" but various international government agencies started snooping around and asking questions about our lists of favorite "hits."

          Kaydia Welcome to the forum! I'm not personally familiar with your piano, but apparently it has internal recording, so you could record and listen back without having to use any phone, tablet or computer. This is an AI generated description of the functionality:

          Casio Privia PX-850 Recording
          To record on the Casio Privia PX-850, follow these steps:

          Press the SONG RECORDER button to activate the song recording mode. The indicator light will illuminate.
          While holding down the FUNCTION button, press the SONG RECORDER (L/R) button to select the track you want to record on.
          Press the SONG RECORDER button again to start recording. The indicator light will start flashing.
          Play the desired song on the keyboard. The recorded track will play simultaneously with your performance.
          To stop the recording, press the SONG RECORDER button.
          To play back the recorded song, press the SONG button. The recorded track will start playing.
          To adjust the tempo while the song is playing, press the SONG button again to stop playback, then use the TEMPO buttons or the + and - keys to adjust the tempo.
          Press the SONG button once more to stop playback.
          Additionally, you can save the recorded song to a USB flash drive. To do this, follow these steps:

          While holding down the FUNCTION button, press the save keyboard key. This will cause the GRAND PIANO (CONCERT) button lamp to light.
          Use the procedure below to save data you recorded on the Digital Piano to a USB flash drive as a MIDI file (SMF format 0).
          For more detailed instructions, refer to the user manual or the online resources provided by Casio.

            candela I'm not personally familiar with your piano, but apparently it has internal recording, so you could record and listen back without having to use any phone, tablet or computer.

            Hi candela. Last night I tried a recording on my phone and the audio was terrible. So I just now tried it out using the instructions you provided and, of course, it sounded great (the audio quality at least), so thank you very much for your help!

            So, what did I learn from my first ever audio recording? The biggest thing was that hearing the pace while I was playing vs how the pace sounded on playback was a surprise. I thought I was playing the New World Symphony Theme in a 'moderately flowing' manner as indicated in the piece. However, while listening to the playback I nearly dozed off as it dragged along. I thought I'd settled on a nice tempo, but it turns out I was actually playing much slower than I'd realized.

            Thanks to everyone for the suggestions/demands/arm-twisting/threats*/etc to record myself. I'm on board now. πŸ˜†

            Edit: *just felt like throwing in a little dramatic flair

              Kaydia in case you don't know already, Faber has audios of the pieces in two different tempos; practice and performance: https://pianoadventures.com/qr/ff1302/

              I was aiming to match to practice tempo for most pieces. And just like you, I thought my tempo was OK until I've listened those recordings. Even "practice tempo"s were always faster πŸ™‚

                Kaydia
                I'm glad the recording worked!
                Yes, that tempo illusion is very familiar. As a beginner the brain gets so busy processing and executing everything that it feels like we're playing sooo fast. It does slowly get better with lots of practice, though, so just hang in there!

                  hebele Oh, very cool! I didn't know that, thank you very much! And, oh yeah, I was playing it way too slow. I've bookmarked the page and will be trying out playing along to the tracks for the rest of the pieces in the book.

                    candela That's encouraging to hear. I'll be hanging in there! πŸ™‚

                    Kaydia

                    Practice the piece first, paying attention to learning to read the notes on the scale, note values (half, quarter, eighth notes, etc and how long to hold them), tempo, key signatures, and counting. Then listen to/watch the recordings/you tube videos to see how close you got to the way it's supposed to be played.

                    If you practiced the piece first, you not only learn the piece but you also begin to learn to spot the rhythm and harmony/melody without needing to listen first. If you listen first, you'll have a harder time learning the other things you need to start picking up on.

                      Player1 I appreciate the advice, thank you. This is the approach I've been taking so far. Sounds like I'm on the right track, so will continue to work on learning the notes, counting, etc. before viewing a video.

                      I finished with both the left-hand and right-hand chords versions of "When the Saints Go Marching In" separately, then went through the challenge of connecting them together on the repeat without there being a gap in the timing. I ended up doing it by using only the left-hand chords version, instead of having to flip to another page. Also, the right-hand version doesn't have the words from the song written in, and I'm not sure why, but it was throwing me off.

                      Now, on to learning the F Major chord.

                        Congrats @Kaydia - sounds like you're making steady progress! Funny, I did the same with When the Saints - it's fun to play both versions back to back and finding ways to reduce the page turning time gap. In fact it's one of the pieces I still play on occasion - it's so happy and bouncy.

                        Mind you, page turning is a skill we need to learn at some point... in fact I may need to face it soon with my current piece (I just started Moonlight Sonata which is two double pages long, yikes).

                        Another piece I really enjoyed playing (and still do) is Mary Ann, I believe that you already had that one. But then again I enjoy calypso type music and it has a very cute left hand melody πŸ™‚

                          Kaydia

                          Be sure to learn your chords and scales by heart both on the keyboard and being able to speak/define/explain them.

                            Kaydia Congratulations with your first recording! πŸ€Έβ€β™€οΈ I wouldn't bother too much with the tempo though in this stage. It will take a lot of time to get it up to speed - I think you'll learn more when you move on to new pieces. You can always go back a couple of months from now and surprise yourself by finding how much easier it all will be.

                            Also, don't bother yet with chords and scales. Too early!

                            As you see, Player1 and I disagree on quite a few things, but that is the nice thing about a forum. You get different answers and you choose the one that suits you the best. 😊

                            *
                            ... feeling like the pianist on the Titanic ...