Right… I’m trying to remember what a friend explained to me about tuning so I can write it here… I think the problem is that there is a range of “acceptability” (for lack of a better word) for a particular note to be “in tune” at a particular frequency. And where one tuner falls in tuning that note could be,say, on the left side of that range, while another tuner could fall on the right side of that range. And so numerically speaking, you might have the same tuning, the tuning competed by tuner #1 will sounded different from the “same” tuning completed by tuner #2.
Oh btw, remember my description of the tuning I didn’t like as “shimmery”? Well I thought it was because maybe it was some kind of slightly well-tempered tuning. But a tuner on another site told me that maybe it was because it was an equal temperament tuning that was “too clinical.” I thought that was fascinating, and also it makes sense because I don’t think the “shimmery tuner” was a bad guy, and I asked him to do an ET tuning, so I have no reason to believe he didn’t.
Back to @Gombessa and my most recent tuning… I don’t think I necessarily have just one tuning that I like, so even if I could get this exact tuning copied, I don’t know that I would… I think the problem is there are clearly some tunings that I specifically don’t like, and all I want to do is avoid those!
It’s complicated though, isn’t it! 🧐