Well, it seems that this forum is a nice refuge from another place that has too many ads and too much drama lately! I see we already have a nice Alfred 1 thread in here, so we might as well get going with Alfred book 2 as well!

In short. I started with the Alfred method in January 2024. I had some prior experience with the piano, so I went through the first book pretty quickly. In March I started the second book and as I'm writing this (May) I'm about halfway in. It's going a LOT slower now because rather than catching up, I'm now learning new skills and facing lots of challenges ๐Ÿ˜ƒ I'm self teaching for several reasons, so I'm using the forum to keep motivated, hopefully motivate others and of course to enjoy the banter and comradery.

Not sure how active this thread will be, because as far as I know, only Nightowl and myself are currently in this level 2 book, but if you're new, please don't hesitate to participate ๐Ÿ™‚

Hi Sophia, I'm glad you started this shiny new thread and I'm looking forward to the kittens popping in from time to time, along with a certain tiger. ๐Ÿ™‚

I am nearly finished with La Bamba, which is good as I'm so bored with it now. Meanwhile I managed to crack Tarantella, a short piece that is pretty straightforward but involves a new fingering technique to move the RH steadily down successive notes, playing a repeated phrase.

Yesterday I started on Festive Dance, a familiar tune which is not too tricky. Pd'A is now tantalisingly close. ๐Ÿ™‚ When I reach that piece it will feel like I'm playing something worth making an effort for. I'm also dipping into my Broadway Hits book and am pleased that the pieces are manageable and give some relief from the tedium of book 2. I view many of the pieces as piano exercises to be ploughed through, rather than enjoyed, but so far I've been fairly diligent and have only skipped one piece.

Progress feels SO slow. No wonder many people lose interest in book 2, the pieces aren't exactly inspiring, but I'm confident that my sight reading is improving.

"Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

I am just starting La Donna รจ Mobile from the opera Rigoletto. Being a tad fickle myself (what woman isn't), I'm really enjoying the piece! It will take some time though. I haven't polished the preceding pieces enough just yet to really move on from them, and I'm having a lot of fun with the blues course.

Plus I'm enjoying this new forum - all it needs is a few more regulars ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

Pallas I'm following the course that @WieWaldi recommended, this one:

I have made it to lesson 3 so far - it's harder than it seems! But he is introducing new concepts gradually enough to keep the challenge manageable ๐Ÿ™‚

    Sophia I have made it to lesson 3 so far - it's harder than it seems! But he is introducing new concepts gradually enough to keep the challenge manageable ๐Ÿ™‚

    This is fast progress. I think I needed almost 1 year and I am still not done with the playlist.
    And you are doing Alfred at the same time? That is amazing!

    Well I'm half thinking of creating an unlisted playlist to record the lessons. I recorded the first one so far but it's not uploaded yet ๐Ÿ˜Š
    I don't expect the 3rd lesson to be finished soon though... I just started it!
    Maybe we should create a beginners blues thread?

      Sophia Maybe we should create a beginners blues thread?

      You should.

      I mean, this thread is about Alfred all in one and we are talking about blues.

      I've just begun work on Scherzo, it's a pleasant enough piece which travels up and down the treble stave quite a bit. It also involves the LH crossing over the RH, which is a novelty for me. The only problem is that it ends on some very high notes which my little keyboard does not have! Yep, the day has come when I've finally run out of notes! I knew this day would come, but didn't realise that it would be so soon. I wasn't really sure I had the ability to progress this far, but now I'm a victim of my own success! ๐Ÿ™‚ This hobby is suddenly going to get a lot more expensive.

      "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

      Thanks Pallas. No, it wouldn't be terrible, it's just a repeat section where you're meant to play it 8VA, so no big deal. It feels like a bit of a milestone for me, in a good way. Trouble is, I'm torn between the idea of a beautiful piano with a highly polished wooden case, and the practical option of a digital piano. I don't really have room for an accoustic without changing the living room around and even then the noise level might make it prohibitive - the sound proofing on the party wall may not be sufficient for a piano that can't be played quietly. Or maybe it can - is there such a thing as a soft pedal option? Piano pedals are a mystery to me, but that is something else I will need to master and no doubt it will be a shock to my system going over old pieces and learning the technique of sustaining notes etc.

      "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

      Whooo hooo our little Nightowl is outgrowing her crib, now there's progress if I ever saw it ๐Ÿ˜

      All jokes aside, that's a tough decision to make! Our 1970s acoustic piano had a mute pedal that you could lock in place, but I hated the sound because it was so muffled. I have no idea if modern pianos have a more sophisticated system than just a layer of felt.

      Our 1990s Clavinova of course can be adjusted to any level and continues to sound gorgeous. It never needs tuning. And when we moved to this house, it didn't require specialized movers. Also, a digital piano is sampled from high-end grand pianos, whereas with an acoustic you may need to spend some time trying to find one with a good sound. Some sound dreadful!

      I think that a really good digital piano might be the best of both worlds, but the two piano sections in this forum might be able to help you make a more informed decision. ๐Ÿ˜Š

      Edit: whoops cross posted!

        The number one thing most forget when piano shopping is maintenance. Acoustic pianos will have a tuner visiting your house 2X per year while a digital won't require that.

        You can get digital pianos in a wooden stand that have all 3 pedals as part of the stand.

        Thanks fellow Alfredos, all input gratefully received. I'm in no rush and will take my time, but it feels weird that I've run out of keys so soon, I thought it wouldn't happen until playing classical pieces at intermediate level.
        Player1, it's good to know that I could get a digital with a wooden case - I'd love it to be beautiful as well as practical. Good point about the tuning, apart from the inconvenience the cost of a few tuning sessions could be more than a cheap digital (although if I want it to be pretty, I guess it won't be cheap).
        Pallas, do you play the digital much, now that you have the acoustic? You seem very pleased with the acoustic, so will you be selling the digital at some point? (Not that I'm in the market to buy it... the cost of shipping it to the UK would rule that out).

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

        Sophia Our 1970s acoustic piano had a mute pedal that you could lock in place, but I hated the sound because it was so muffled. I have no idea if modern pianos have a more sophisticated system than just a layer of felt.

        Mine doesn't, and I bought it new 4 years ago. I had never experienced a practice pedal and loved the idea, but it makes the piano sound so horrible that I won't use it. Some people don't seem to think it's too bad so it must vary by manufacturer.

        Well, I got La Donna e Mobile to the polishing stage now. It's cute, but every time I play it, my mind sings "Ta ra ra boom de ay" followed by some very rude lyrics that we sang in kindergarten... but other than that I like it ๐Ÿ˜ƒ

        Great progress Sophia. I keep thinking of Santa Lucia when I hear that piece - I'm not sure if one is based on the other or if I'm just conflating two similar pieces? Anyway, you're way ahead of me (and always will be), but I'm happy enough playing Scherzo and have recently begun working on Introduction and Dance. This piece was the basis for Those were The Days - here's a link of the version that plays in my head when I think of this old song:

        [

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

        Very nice! That's the way I remember that tune too. This is the one I'm finalizing:

        We watched that concert live on TV at the time and I always thought that Pavarotti looked a bit distracted or even inebriated, the way he was jiggling and consulting his notes. But the singing is impeccable ๐Ÿ™‚

        It sounds great in Italian, and is a really iconic piece, but now that I've read the lyrics using the subtitles, I'm surprised about how chauvinistic they are! In the context of the story line in the opera there were probably reasons why the character felt like slagging off all women, so I'm not suggesting they should rewrite the lyrics to fit with today's PC world (there is too much of that going on already), but those lyrics are bad.
        Every day's a school day for me, on my journey into classical music. ๐Ÿ™‚

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

        Haha I know right? When I was little my mom used to take me to operas. I didn't understand a word of course and I was bored out of my skull. Then in later years the theater installed an overhead "ticker tape" subtitling feature, so you could follow what was going on. Ok, I confess - I was still bored - but at least then I realized that they weren't just yelling because they sat on something, there was an actual story attached ๐Ÿ˜†

        7 days later

        Well, I'm now playing Laredo - a tune that sounded familiar so I searched on YT and found several videos of different people singing this old folk song, including Johnny Cash. I must have heard this version on the radio when I was very young, because my mother always had the radio on in the kitchen and JC's version was quite popular back then. The pieces in book 2 are certainly more interesting than book 1, and the next song is Pd'A. It felt like I'd never reach this point but now I'm getting nervous about starting that piece, wondering if I'll be able to do it justice.
        Meanwhile there is another piece about 50 pages on that is on my wish list to play - a Chopin Etude. It looks really scary but sounds so beautiful when I hear proper pianists playing it on YT.
        I feel like things are clicking into place a bit now, and the early pieces in book 2 have helped to improve my sight reading.

        "Don't let's ask for the moon, we have the stars." (Final line from Now,Voyager, 1942)

        Nice! I am still learning the waltz. Right now I'm only practicing about half an hour a day... spring has finally landed and it's hard to stay indoors ๐Ÿ˜

        So between Alfred and the blues course I'm not really progressing very fast right now, but I know I'll be back at it in full swing soon enough again.