danno858 My piano's tuning was fairly stable, but I would notice a change in mid winter and again mid spring. I used to have it tuned twice a year.
To me, this sounds about right, and about the same as my piano. I guess the question would be, when you noticed the change, how much of a change was it. When you get your piano back from being rebuilt, you will have a period of adjustment because the strings will be new so it will probably be a while before you can figure out how much humidity changes impact the tuning stability.
Iāve had my grand since 2019 (purchased used, itās a 2000 Yamaha C2) and it has been very stable throughout. When tuning time rolls around, the tuners have always said āitās only barely moved.ā I installed the damp chaser not because it was unstable, but because we moved north and our new state gets a lot colder in the winter, and cold (indoors and out) means low humidity. But I do think the damp chaser helps the piano in a general sense, in terms of tuning stability and in terms of protecting it.
I canāt remember if I posted about this in this thread, but I had my piano tuned in June 2023, and then when my tuner came back on Dec 30th, we were in the middle of a really bad cold snap and I think the RH was like barely 25% in the piano room. My piano sounded a littleā¦ hard, I think just from the general impact of the low humidity. But the tuning was pretty good and it really wasnāt out of tune. My tuner told me he could tune it if I wanted him to, but it really didnāt need it, and he recommended against tuning it until the cold snap passed. So he ended up leaving that day without doing anything and now heās coming back next week (yay!)
Oh and it was that week that I decided to get out the humidifier, which I hadnāt done since the previous winter prior to that cold snap, which started just a few days before the tuner was scheduled. The RH in the room hasnāt increased significantly with the humidifier, but it didnāt drop below 25% even as the cold snap worsened and continued. And the evaporative humidifiers are kind of āgentleā in their humidifying, they say that the actual percentage doesnāt increase a lot because things like furniture in the room and curtains soak up the humidity, which is what we want for the piano, so I think itās ok.
Now the weather is more normal for this time of year, and the RH in the piano room is around 35%, sometimes a little higher.
Also once the humidity got back up to 35%, the intense āhardnessā that I noticed mellowed out. And now it sounds like the tuning has shifted a bit and I think it needs to be tuned, but itās not horribly off. Iāll be interested to see what my tuner thinks about it.
By the way, I think that hardness is just from the hammers, which makes sense. The damp chaser is on the bottom of the piano and mainly helps the soundboard, and because the soundboard blocks the hammers from the damp chaser, I wouldnāt expect the hammers to get much benefit from the DC. And of course thatās why people say increasing the room humidity is more ideal for the piano than using a DC. But increasing the room humidity is a lot harder.
Anyway, this post is starting to get long so Iāll wrap up for now. š